Contacts

The Networking Paradox: Knowing More People Can Make You Less Trustworthy

, by Andrea Costa
Professional connections can open doors, but they can also raise suspicion. New research reveals why successful networking depends not just on who you know, but on how you communicate the value of your relationships

In the business world, knowing the right people is often considered a passport to success. A well-connected professional can introduce colleagues to new clients, bring together experts from different departments, or create collaborations that would otherwise never happen. But there is a catch: the people best positioned to connect others may also be the ones others are least inclined to trust.

Imagine a colleague offering to introduce you to someone who could transform your project. You know that your colleague has an impressive network, but you have few mutual acquaintances. How can you be sure the recommendation is reliable? Is your colleague genuinely trying to help, or pursuing an agenda of their own?

This dilemma lies at the heart of a study published in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes by Garrett L. Brady of Bocconi University’s Department of Management and Technology, together with Raina A. Brands of University College London and Ajay Mehra of the University of Kentucky.

They explore a fundamental contradiction in professional networking: the very connections that make someone an effective intermediary can undermine the trust needed to turn introductions into successful collaborations.

The hidden disadvantage of being well-connected

Social network research has long established that people who connect otherwise disconnected groups enjoy important advantages. They can access diverse information, identify opportunities others overlook, and introduce people whose skills or interests complement each other.

Researchers refer to the gaps between disconnected groups as structural holes. Professionals who bridge these gaps are known as brokers. Yet brokerage involves more than simply knowing people. Its success depends on whether others are willing to act on the broker’s recommendations.

“the network structures that enable brokers to spot valuable referral opportunities also make brokers appear less trustworthy.”

As the authors explain, “the network structures that enable brokers to spot valuable referral opportunities also make brokers appear less trustworthy.” The problem is that professionals who operate across different social circles often lack mutual acquaintances with the people they approach. This makes their competence harder to verify and their intentions more difficult to assess. Shared contacts, by contrast, provide valuable information about someone’s reputation. They can also discourage opportunistic behavior because misconduct is more likely to become known.

The result is a paradox: brokers have more opportunities to connect people, but fewer built-in guarantees that those connections will be trusted.

Can talking about your network make people trust you?

To investigate this problem, Brady and his coauthors examined a behavior they call network self-promotion: actively communicating the quality of one’s professional relationships, one’s networking abilities, and one’s previous successes in connecting people. Unlike conventional self-promotion, which emphasizes individual accomplishments, network self-promotion highlights the value that someone can create through their relationships.

The researchers began with a field study at a British accounting and business advisory firm, where introducing clients to colleagues was an important part of professional practice. They conducted 36 interviews and collected usable survey responses from 206 partners, examining how their professional networks and self-promotion behaviors related to referrals accepted by colleagues.

Brokers with more disconnected networks tended to achieve more accepted referrals overall. Crucially, this advantage was stronger among those who actively promoted their networks and networking skills. The interviews also exposed the delicate balance involved. Professionals recognized that remaining silent about their connections could mean missing opportunities, while excessive self-promotion might damage their reputation.

One partner captured the tension particularly well: “you do need a bit of self-publicity.”

But simply boasting about knowing influential people is not necessarily the answer. What appears to matter is whether self-promotion provides useful information that others would otherwise lack.

Trust is not one thing: ability, integrity and benevolence

To better understand why network self-promotion works, the researchers conducted two additional experiments, manipulating the information participants received about a hypothetical colleague offering a professional referral.

Across the studies, the researchers distinguished three dimensions of trust: ability, integrity and benevolence. Ability concerns whether someone has the competence to make a good recommendation. Integrity reflects whether that person follows acceptable principles and can be relied upon to behave consistently. Benevolence captures whether they genuinely care about others’ interests rather than exclusively pursuing their own. The distinction produced an important discovery: network self-promotion does not influence all forms of trust in the same way.

When mutual contacts cannot provide information about a broker’s competence, highlighting previous successful introductions can help compensate for that missing reputational evidence. In other words, communicating networking expertise can partly substitute for the reassurance normally supplied by shared acquaintances.

Integrity works differently. Here, network self-promotion is most effective when shared connections already provide a foundation of credibility. Communicating one’s networking abilities reinforces the trust conveyed by those relationships.

Benevolence, however, follows another pattern. The researchers found no evidence that network self-promotion systematically changed the relationship between benevolence-based trust and referral acceptance.

This means that explaining how well-connected you are may convince someone that you know what you are doing, but it does not necessarily convince them that you have their best interests at heart.

The right kind of self-promotion matters

These findings challenge the assumption that professional networking success depends mainly on accumulating contacts. The size and structure of a network matter, but so does the ability to communicate its value.

For professionals working across organizational boundaries, this has obvious implications. A consultant introducing a client to a specialist, a manager assembling a cross-functional team, or an entrepreneur connecting potential business partners can benefit from demonstrating why their connections are relevant and credible.

The most persuasive approach is not necessarily to emphasize the number or status of one’s contacts. It is to provide meaningful evidence of networking competence: explaining the experience behind a recommendation, describing previous successful collaborations, or showing an understanding of what makes two people a good professional match.

There are limits, however. The authors note that exaggerated or inauthentic self-promotion can backfire, creating precisely the suspicion it is intended to overcome. Networking then should not be treated as a numbers game. Introducing people carries reputational risks, both for the person making the recommendation and for those accepting it.

The research also suggests that organizations seeking greater collaboration should pay attention not only to how connections are created but also to how referrals are communicated and received.

From collecting contacts to earning trust

The study offers a different perspective on professional influence. Being well-connected is not enough: the advantages of an extensive network emerge only when others are willing to trust the person who activates it.

“Brokers, therefore, are not powerless inheritors of the trust implications of their networks; they can work to reshape them.”

As the authors conclude, “Brokers, therefore, are not powerless inheritors of the trust implications of their networks; they can work to reshape them.”

Brady and his colleagues then move beyond the traditional view that our place in a social network largely determines the advantages we enjoy. People can also influence how others interpret their connections.

Key takeaways

  • Having many contacts does not guarantee trust. Those who connect different professional groups have more opportunities, but may be seen as less reliable by others.
  • Communicating the value of your network can make all the difference. Demonstrating your networking skills and the results you've achieved helps overcome mistrust, especially when there are no shared connections.
  • Trust takes many forms. Self-promotion can reinforce the perception of competence and integrity, but it is not enough to convince others of the sincerity of one's intentions.

GARRETT LEVY BRADY

Bocconi University
Department of Management and Technology