Contacts
From penicillin to Post-it Notes, unexpected discoveries have fueled the myth of innovation through luck. But a study of more than 8,500 patents reveals a paradox: unplanned inventions are less likely to become products of the companies that created them, yet they can find value in the market for technology

Penicillin, the microwave oven, Post-it Notes: some of the world’s most famous inventions originated from unexpected discoveries. These stories suggest that a stroke of luck can lead to extraordinary success. But are accidental inventions really more valuable than planned ones? And, more importantly, who stands to profit from them?

A study published in the Strategic Management Journal puts this popular belief to the test. The research was conducted by Myriam Mariani, of Bocconi University’s Department of Management and Technology and its ICRIOS research center, together with Christoph Grimpe of Copenhagen Business School, Karin Hoisl of the University of Mannheim and the Max Planck Institute for Innovation and Competition, and Wolfgang Sofka of Copenhagen Business School and the University of Liverpool.

Analyzing 8,530 patented inventions across 23 countries, the researchers found that serendipity, the ability to arrive at valuable outcomes without having planned them, is far from exceptional: 42.8% of the inventions examined emerged unexpectedly. Surprisingly, however, these inventions were, on average, less likely to have a major technological impact, become products commercialized by the companies that developed them, or be used to block competitors.

The value paradox of unexpected innovation

One significant finding concerns how inventions generate value. Unplanned inventions are more frequently associated with licensing agreements that allow other companies to exploit them commercially. An invention can be promising without being well suited to the capabilities, products, or markets of the organization that created it. A company may lack the complementary technologies, manufacturing capabilities, or distribution channels needed to develop it.

As the authors write, 

“These inventions embody latent ‘potential’ that, although not realized within the originating firm, becomes valuable when developed elsewhere.”

The potential of an invention, therefore, may only be realized when it finds the right organization.

Freedom to experiment matters, but is not enough

Freedom to experiment does not guarantee success. Unexpected inventions also tend to be less closely related to the technological knowledge a company already possesses. This mismatch helps explain why it is often easier to create value from such inventions through other organizations than to develop them internally.

This distance from a company’s existing expertise helps explain why firms struggle to exploit unexpected inventions themselves. Serendipity, after all, is not simply a matter of luck. As the authors emphasize, 

“Serendipitous inventions are not just random occurrences or luck.”

Seizing an unexpected opportunity requires expertise, the ability to recognize its potential, and appropriate strategic decisions. Investing in innovation is not just about organizing research and developing new products. It also means learning to recognize the value of discoveries that emerge outside the original plan and building the capabilities needed to license patents or transfer technologies to others.